To advance and promote the discipline and professional practice of epidemiology in Ontario public health units
Please click here to visit our new website











 

 

 

4C Seat Belt Use
Description | Specific Indicators | Ontario Public Health Standards (OPHS) | Corresponding Health Indicator(s) from Statistics Canada and CIHI | Corresponding Indicator(s) from Other Sources | Data Sources |  Alternative Data Sources | Analysis Check List | Method of Calculation |  Basic Categories | Indicator Comments | Cross-References to Other Sections | Cited References | Changes Made | Acknowledgements

Description  
  • Prevalence of seatbelt use among motor vehicle drivers
  • Prevalence of seatbelt use among motor vehicle passengers 12 years of age and older
Specific Indicators  
  • Proportion of motor vehicle drivers, 16 years of age and older, that "always" wear a seat belt when driving
  • Proportion of passengers, 12 years of age and older,  that "always" wear a seat belt when driven in a motor vehicle
Ontario Public Health Standards (OPHS) 
The Ontario Public Health Standards (OPHS) establish requirements for the fundamental public health programs and services carried out by boards of health, which include assessment and surveillance, health promotion and policy development, disease and injury prevention, and health protection. The OPHS consist of one Foundational Standard and 13 Program Standards that articulate broad societal goals that result from the activities undertaken by boards of health and many others, including community partners, non-governmental organizations, and governmental bodies. These results have been expressed in terms of two levels of outcomes: societal outcomes and board of health outcomes. Societal outcomes entail changes in health status, organizations, systems, norms, policies, environments, and practices and result from the work of many sectors of society, including boards of health, for the improvement of the overall health of the population. Board of health outcomes are the results of endeavours by boards of health and often focus on changes in awareness, knowledge, attitudes, skills, practices, environments, and policies. Boards of health are accountable for these outcomes. The standards also outline the requirements that boards of health must implement to achieve the stated results.

 
Outcomes Related to this Indicator
  • Board of Health Outcome (Prevention of Injury and Substance Misuse): the board of health shall conduct epidemiological analysis of surveillance data....in the areas of injury and substance misuse outcomes, including road and off-road safety (of pedestrians, cyclists, drivers and occupants)...and drinking and driving.
  • Board of Health Outcome (Foundational Standard): the public, community partners and health care providers are aware of relevant and current population health information
Assessment and Surveillance Requirements Related to this Indicator
  • The board of health shall conduct epidemiological analysis of surveillance data....in the areas of road and off-road safety

http://www.ontario.ca/publichealthstandards

Corresponding Health Indicator(s) from Statistics Canada and CIHI

  • None 
Corresponding Indicator(s) from Other Sources
  •  None
Data Source(s) (see Resources: Data Sources

Numerator & Denominator:
Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS)
Original source:
Statistics Canada
Distributed by: Ontario Ministry of Health and Long Term Care (MOHLTC)
Suggested citation (see Data Citation Notes): Canadian Community Health Survey Cycle [year], Statistics Canada, Share File, Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care

Survey Questions   
   

Data source

Module

Questions

Response categories

Year

Variable

CCHS

Driving and Safety (DRV)

In the past twelve months have you driven a motor vehicle?

1 Yes

2 No

DK, R, not stated

2009/2010

DRV_01A

2007/2008

*

2005

*

2003

DRVC_01A

2001

*

How often do you fasten your seat belt when you drive a motor vehicle?

1 Always

2 Most of the time

3 Rarely

4 Never

DK, R, not stated

2009/2010

DRV_02

2007/2008

*

2005

*

2003

DRVC_02

2001

*

When you are a front seat passenger, how often do you fasten your seat belt?

1 Always

2 Most of the time

3 Rarely

4 Never

DK, R, not stated, do not ride in front seat

2009/2010

DRV_08A

2007/2008

*

2005

*

2003

DRVC_08A

2001

*

When you are a back seat passenger, how often do you fasten your seat belt?

1 Always

2 Most of the time

3 Rarely

4 Never

DK, R, not stated, do not ride in back seat

2009/2010

DRV_08B

2007/2008

*

2005

*

2003

DRVC_08B

2001

*

When you are a passenger in a taxi, how often do you fasten your seat belt?

1 Always

2 Most of the time

3 Rarely

4 Never

DK, R, not stated, do not take taxis

2009/2010

DRV_09

2007/2008

*

2005

*

2003

DRVC_09

2001

*

* module not selected by any Ontario health region or not included in the CCHS survey year or question not included in the module

 

Alternative Data Source(s) 


Numerator & Denominator:
Rapid Risk Factor Surveillance System (RRFSS)
Original source: Public Health Units
Distributed by: Public Health Units
Suggested citation (see Data Citation Notes): Rapid Risk Factor Surveillance System [month, year - month, year], Extracted: [month,year]

 

Survey Questions
 

Data source

Module

Questions

Response categories

Year*

Variable

RRFSS

Driving Status

In the past 12 months have you driven a motor vehicle?                 

1 Yes

5 No

DK, R

2004

drv_1

Seat Belt Use

How often do you wear a seat belt when you drive a car, van or truck?

1 All of the time

2 Most of the time

3 About half the time

4 Less than half the time

5 Never or almost never

7 Volunteers they do not drive

DK, R

2001

sb1

How often do you wear a seat belt when you are a passenger in a car, van or truck

1 All of the time

2 Most of the time

3 About half the time

4 Less than half the time

5 Never or almost never

7 Volunteers they are never a passenger in a car

DK, R

2001

sb2

*Year module was first available. Classification of modules, (i.e. core, core rotating, optional, seasonal), and selection of modules by health units varies by year. Please refer to RRFSS the website (RRFSS Inventory) for details. 

 

Analysis Check List 
 
CCHS Data
  • It is recommended that public health units use the Share File provided by the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care rather than public use file (PUMF) provided by Statistics Canada. The Share File has a slightly smaller sample size because respondents must agree to share their information with the province to be included; however, the share file has more variables and fewer grouped categories within variables. The Share File is a cleaner dataset for Ontario analysis because all variables that were not common content, theme content or optional content for Ontario have been removed.
  • There may be slight differences between results from the share file and data published on the Statistics Canada website for the Health Indicators because rates calculated for Health Indicators use the master CCHS data file.
  • Not applicable respondents should be excluded; however, it is important to understand who these respondents are from the questionnaire skip patterns to be able to describe the relevant population.
  • Users need to consider whether or not to exclude the ‘Refusal, 'Don't Know' and ‘Not Stated' response categories in the denominator. Rates published in most reports, including Statistics Canada's publication Health Reports generally exclude these response categories. In removing not stated responses from the denominator, the assumption is that the missing values are random, and this is not always the case. This is particularly important when the proportion in these response categories is high.
  • Estimates must be appropriately weighted (generally the share weight for the CCHS) and rounded.
  • Users of the CCHS Ontario Share File must adhere to Statistics Canada's release guidelines for the CCHS data when publishing or releasing data derived from the file in any form. Refer to the appropriate user guide for guidelines for tabulation, analysis and release of data from the CCHS. In general, when calculating the CV from the share file using the bootstrap weights, users should not use or release weighted estimates when the unweighted cell count is below 10. For ratios or proportions, this rule should be applied to the numerator of the ratio.  Statistics Canada uses this approach for the tabular data on their website. When using only the Approximate Sampling Variability (CV) lookup tables for the share file, data may not be released when the unweighted cell count is below 30. This rule should be applied to the numerator for ratios or proportions.  This provides a margin of safety in terms of data quality, given the CV being utilized is only approximate.
  • Before releasing and/or publishing data, users should determine the CV of the rounded weighted estimate and follow the guidelines below:
    • Acceptable (CV of 0.0 - 16.5%) Estimates can be considered for general unrestricted release. Requires no special notation.
    • Marginal (CV of 16.6 - 33.3%) Estimates can be considered for general unrestricted release but should be accompanied by a warning cautioning subsequent users of the high sampling variability associated with the estimates. Such estimates should be identified by the letter E (or in some other similar fashion).
    • Unacceptable (CV greater than 33.3%) Statistics Canada recommends not to release estimates of unacceptable quality. However, if the user chooses to do so then estimates should be flagged with the letter F (or in some other fashion) and the following warning should accompany the estimates: "The user is advised that...(specify the data)...do not meet Statistics Canada's quality standards for this statistical program. Conclusions based on these data will be unreliable and most likely invalid". These data and any consequent findings should not be published. If the user chooses to publish these data or findings, then this disclaimer must be published with the data.
  • Caution should be taken when comparing the results from Cycle 1.1 (2000/01) to subsequent years of the survey, due to a change in the mode of data collection.  The sample in Cycle 1.1 had a higher proportion of respondents interviewed in person, which affected the comparability of some key health indicators.  Please refer to http://www.statcan.gc.ca/imdb-bmdi/document/3226_D16_T9_V1-eng.pdf for a full text copy of the Statistics Canada article entitled "Mode effects in the Canadian Community Health Survey: a Comparison of CAPI and CATI".
RRFSS Data
  • Users should refer to the most recent RRFSS Manual of Operations for a complete list of RRFSS analysis guidelines.
  • Denominator Data - cell size less than 30 not to be released (based on unweighted data).
  • Numerator Data - cell size less than 5 not to be released (based on unweighted data).
  • Coefficients of variation (CV) should be calculated for every estimate. The following categories determine the release of the data:
    • CV between 0 and 16.5:  estimate can be released without qualification.
    • CV between 16.6 and 33.3:  estimate can be released with qualification:  interpret with caution.  High variability.
    • CV greater than 33.3:  estimate should not be released, regardless of the cell size.
  • 95% confidence intervals should accompany all released estimates.  In general the simple computation of the C.I. for a proportion assuming SEp = sqrt(pq/n) and CI95% = p +/- 1.96*SEp is sufficient. However, if estimates are close to 0 or 100% and the simple computation confidence intervals include values less than zero or greater than 100 then the Fleiss 2nd edition computation for skewed estimates should be employed.
  • Weighting:
    • General household weight will be applied for questions related to the individual. 
    • Household weight is to be applied for questions about households when we wish to determine the population/number of people affected. 
    • Household weight is not to be applied for child proxy questions (bicycle helmet use, car seat safety), dog and cat immunization modules, or other questions that relate to the household rather than the respondent. 
    • Household weights are not required to be recalculated for sub-population based questions; for example mammography in women ages 35+ years and 50-74 years.
    • If the weights supplied with the data set (health unit wave specific, health unit cumulative total, all health units combined wave specific, all health units combined cumulative total) are not appropriate for the required analysis, then a time-specific weight must be calculated.  For example, a new weight is required for all seasonal modules.
  • If the cell size of ‘Don't Know' responses is 5% or greater, ‘Don't Know' responses should be included in the denominator of the analyses and reported separately.
  • If the cell size of ‘Refusal' responses is 5% or greater, ‘Refusal' responses should be included in the denominator of the analyses and reported separately.
  • When an indicator is being compared between groups (e.g. health units, time periods, gender), if any one group has ‘Don't Know' and/or ‘Refusal' responses that are 5% or greater, ‘Don't Know' and/or ‘Refusal' responses should be included in the denominator of the analyses and reported separately for all groups.
  • A provincial sample is not available with the RRFSS.
Refer to the RRFSS Data Dictionaries at for more information about module questions. http://www.rrfss.ca/

Method of Calculation 
Proportion of the population, 16 years of age and older, that always wear a seatbelt as a driver

Weighted number of motor vehicle drivers, 16 years of age and older, that ALWAYS wear a seatbelt as a driver in the past 12 months (dhh_age >15 & drv_02=1) 

    x 100 

Weighted total number of respondents 16 years of age and over that drove in the past 12 months (dhh_age > 15 & drv_01a=1)

 

 

Proportion of the population, 12 years of age and older, that always wear a seat belt while a passenger in the front or back seat of a motor vehicle 

Weighted number of respondents, 12 years of age and older, that ALWAYS wear a seat belt while a passenger in the front or back of a motor vehicle (drv_08a = 1 & drv_08B=1)

    x 100

Weighted total number of respondents that were front seat or back seat passengers (drv_08a = 1-4 or drv_08b = 1-4)

 

Proportion of the population, 12 years of age and older, that always wear a seat belt while a passenger in the front of a motor vehicle

 Weighted number of respondents, 12 years of age and older, that ALWAYS wear a seat belt while a passenger in the front of a motor vehicle (drv_08a=1)

    x 100 

Weighted total number of respondents that were front seat passengers  (drv_08a= 1-4)

 

Proportion of the population, 12 years of age and older, that always wear a seat belt while a passenger in the back of a motor vehicle

 Weighted number of respondents, 12 years of age and older, that ALWAYS wear a seat belt while a passenger in the back of a motor vehicle (drv_08b=1)   

    x 100 

Weighted number of respondents that were back seat passengers  (drv_08b= 1-4)


Proportion of the population, 12 years of age and older, that always wear a seat belt while a passenger in a taxi 

Weighted number  of respondents, 12 years of age and older, that ALWAYS wear a seat belt while a passenger in a taxi  (drv_09= 1)  

    x 100 

Weighted number of respondents that were taxi passengers  (drv_09= 1-4)

 

Basic Categories  
  • Age groups:
  • Age groups:
    • CCHS: 16-24, 25-44, 45-64, 65+
    • RRFSS: 18-24, 25-44, 45-64, 65+
  • Sex: male, female and total
  • Geographic areas: 
    • CCHS data: Ontario, public health unit
    • RRFSS data: RRFSS-participating health units that chose the 'Driving Status' and 'Seat Belt Use' modules. (Varies by wave. Check documentation). 

 

Indicator Comments
  • Mandatory seat-belt use has been one of the greatest success stories of road injury prevention and has saved many lives.
  • Several studies on the benefits of seat-belts for drivers and front-seat passengers have found that seat-belts can reduce the risk of all injuries by 40-50%; of serious injuries by 43-65%; and of fatal injuries by 40-60% (1).
  • Prior to 2007, CCHS data collection occurred every two years on an annual period. Data are available for the 2001, 2003 and 2005 periods. In 2007, major changes were made to the survey design with the goal of improving its effectiveness and flexibility through data collection on an ongoing basis. Data collection now occurs every year, from January through December, rather than every two years as was the case prior to 2007 (2).  
  • "Driving and Safety" module is optional content in the CCHS and was selected as follows:
    • 2000/2001 (cycle 1.1): not included in CCHS
    • 2003 (cycle 2.1): all Ontario health regions
    • 2005 (cycle 3.1): not included in CCHS
    • 2007/2008: no Ontario health regions
    • 2009/2010: all Ontario health regions
Cross-References to Other Sections  
Cited References  
  1. Peden M, Scurfield R, Sleet D, Mohan D, Hyder AA, Jarawan E, et al (editors). World report on road traffic injury prevention. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2004 [cited 2012 Jan 14]. Available from: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/42871/1/9241562609.pdf.
  2. Statistics Canada [homepage on the Internet]. Ottawa: Statistics Canada; 2012 Nov 27 [cited 2013 Apr 18]. Canadian Community Health Survey 2010. Available from: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/cgi-bin/imdb/p2SV.pl?Function=getSurvey&SDDS=3226&lang=en&db=imdb&adm=8&dis=2.
Changes Made
 

Date

Type of Review (Formal Review or Ad Hoc?)

Changes made by

Changes

February 14, 2012

Formal Review

Injury and Substance Misuse Prevention Work Group

  • Replaced Mandatory Health Programs section with Ontario Public Health Standards outcomes.
  • CCHS added as data source.
  • Basic Categories section revised to reflect categories available through IntelliHEALTH Ontario.
  • Indicator comments and references updated.

 

Acknowledgements

Lead Authors

  • Jeremy Herring, Public Health Ontario

Contributing Authors

  • Injury and Substance Misuse Prevention Subgroup
    • Suzanne Fegan, KFL&A Public Health (Subgroup Lead)
    • Christina Bradley, Niagara Region Public Health
    • Badal Dhar, Public Health Ontario
    • Natalie Greenidge, Public Health Ontario
    • Sean Marshall, Public Health Ontario
    • Jayne Morrish, Parachute
    • Lee-Ann Nalezyty, Northwestern Health Unit
    • Michelle Policarpio, Public Health Ontario
    • Narhari Timilshina, Toronto General Hospital

Reviewers

  • John Barbaro, Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit
Treasurer/Secretary | Admin | Members Login

BrickHost